About Fresco Furnishings

If you're looking for a Columbus Ohio furniture consignment store that feels more like a designer boutique than a secondhand shop, Fresco Furnishings on West Fifth Avenue is exactly that. Founded in 2007 by Anne Robinson — a former interior designer who brought her trained eye for quality and arrangement to the resale world — Fresco has become a staple of the Grandview Heights shopping corridor and one of the most consistently well-reviewed furniture destinations in central Ohio, carrying a 4.7-star rating across 160+ Google reviews.

The 4,800 square foot shop houses thousands of pre-owned items restocked daily, offering a mix of high-end designer brands, mid-century modern pieces, original artwork, and eclectic home décor that you genuinely won't find at big-box retailers. Robinson's background in interior design shows in every corner — the store is merchandised and staged with the same intentionality you'd see in a curated showroom, not piled on shelves like typical resale operations.

What Makes This Columbus Ohio Furniture Consignment Store Different

Fresco's curation is what separates it from every other resale shop on Fifth Avenue. The inventory is strictly vetted — no junk, no damaged goods masquerading as "vintage," no mass-produced filler. What does make it through the door includes brands like Article, West Elm, Arhaus, and Lulu & Georgia alongside genuine mid-century credenzas, designer barstools, and one-of-a-kind accent pieces. Prices typically run 50–70% off original retail, which means you're getting authenticated quality at a fraction of new pricing.

The art collection deserves its own mention. Fresco carries original artwork — signed oil paintings, local Ohio artists, global pieces brought back from travels — at prices that make gallery shopping accessible. Multiple reviewers specifically call out finding gallery-sized original paintings for under $200. For anyone decorating a home or staging a property, this Columbus Ohio furniture consignment store offers a sourcing advantage that most resale shops can't match.

Shopping Experience and Staff

The in-store experience reflects Robinson's philosophy that consignment shopping should be fun, not frustrating. Staff members are genuinely helpful without being pushy — a balance that reviewers mention repeatedly. They're known for helping customers visualize pieces in their own spaces, often encouraging shoppers to bring in room photos so the team can offer placement and styling suggestions. This is the interior design background showing up as a free service layer on top of the retail experience.

The store doesn't smell like a thrift shop — a detail that sounds trivial but matters enormously to the shopping experience. It's clean, well-organized, and arranged with visual intent. The tight 4,800 square foot footprint means the space is full but not overwhelming — you can browse the entire store in under an hour, which makes this a Columbus Ohio furniture consignment store that works for both dedicated treasure hunters and casual lunch-break shoppers.

Buying and Selling at Fresco

Fresco operates both consignment and outright purchase models. If you're selling, you can choose between consignment (90-day period with scheduled price drops) or selling directly to the store for immediate payout — a flexibility that most consignment-only shops don't offer. Pricing on consigned items follows a tiered markdown schedule, meaning items decrease in price over time. Savvy shoppers who track specific pieces can wait for price drops, while sellers benefit from a structured system that keeps inventory fresh and moving.

The e-commerce platform at frescofurnishings.com lists current inventory with photos and dimensions, making it possible to shop remotely. Out-of-state buyers have successfully purchased and arranged pickup or shipping. Fresco also runs a digital rewards program for frequent shoppers, adding an extra discount layer for regulars. While the store doesn't provide delivery directly, they maintain a list of preferred local movers to help with large furniture transport. Visit frescofurnishings.com for current inventory and consignment details.

Location on West Fifth Avenue

Fresco Furnishings sits at 1744 W 5th Ave in the heart of the Grandview Heights shopping corridor — a stretch of Columbus known for independent consignment stores, boutiques, and restaurants. As the anchor Columbus Ohio furniture consignment store on the street, Fresco draws both local regulars and visitors from across central Ohio. Combined with neighboring shops, it's easy to make a full afternoon of consignment browsing along the West Fifth Avenue strip.