About One More Time Etc.

If you're searching for a Columbus Ohio furniture consignment shop with real history and proven inventory depth, One More Time Etc. on West 5th Avenue is the city's longest-running furniture resale destination. Part of the One More Time Family of Stores — a locally-owned Columbus institution since 1975 — the furniture location opened in 2004 under President Christine E. Swanson and has grown into over 9,000 square feet of consignment furniture, patio pieces, and home decor. With over 29,000 consignors in the system and an A+ BBB rating, this isn't a startup hoping to gain traction. It's a half-century-old business that has earned its reputation one transaction at a time.

The store operates on a simple, consignor-friendly model: bring furniture in any day with no appointment needed, and the team handles pricing, display, and sale. Consignors receive 50% of the selling price, with a buyout option available for those who prefer immediate cash. This open-door consignment policy keeps the inventory flowing constantly — new pieces arrive daily, which means the selection changes with every visit and regulars know that timing and frequency are the keys to finding the best pieces.

Columbus Ohio Furniture Consignment Shop Inventory

The 9,000-square-foot showroom carries furniture spanning the full style spectrum — antique and retro pieces sit alongside classic and contemporary designs, creating a browsing experience that appeals to diverse tastes and budgets. Indoor furniture includes dining sets, sofas, accent chairs, bedroom furniture, home office pieces, and case goods. The patio furniture section is a differentiator that most Columbus consignment shops don't offer, expanding the store's relevance to seasonal outdoor furnishing needs.

Reviewers consistently praise the ability to find real wood furniture at reasonable prices — a significant draw in an era where most new furniture is manufactured with particle board and veneer. The quality of the inventory reflects the volume of consignors feeding the pipeline. With nearly 30,000 consignors over the store's history, the range of styles, eras, and quality levels ensures that both budget shoppers and premium furniture hunters find options worth considering. This Columbus Ohio furniture consignment shop serves a genuinely broad audience.

The Shopping Experience

Reviewers describe One More Time Etc. as a "treasure hunt" — every visit produces unexpected finds, and the daily inventory turnover means the floor never looks the same twice. The staff is consistently described as friendly and helpful, and the frequent shopper reward card program adds a loyalty incentive: earn points toward a $25 credit on future purchases. Pick-up and delivery service throughout the greater Columbus area makes large furniture purchases convenient for buyers who don't want to rent a truck.

The store's location on West 5th Avenue puts it alongside its sister stores — One More Time (clothing) and One More Time Plus (plus-size fashion) — creating a consignment destination cluster that draws shoppers for multiple purposes. The annual charity sale, which has donated over $80,000 since 1995, reflects a business embedded in the Columbus community for decades. This Columbus Ohio furniture consignment shop has built the kind of customer loyalty that only comes from consistent quality and fair dealing over a long period.

Location and Planning Your Visit

One More Time Etc. is located at 1641 W. 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212 — in the Grandview Heights area, easily accessible from I-670 and Route 33. Open Tuesday through Saturday 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM, Monday by appointment only. Closed Sunday. Inventory turns over daily, so visit often for the best Columbus Ohio furniture consignment shop selection. Call (614) 486-7571 or email manager.omtetc@gmail.com for delivery scheduling or consignment inquiries. Visit onemoretimeetc.com for current inventory and hours.